The notices, the features, and the conversations — what the critics say about the work, and what Gerry says about the work.
What the Critics Say
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat — North Shore Music Theatre, 2026
“Precision-perfect direction and choreography by Gerry McIntyre match Robert L. Rucinski’s always luminous musical direction as the cast and children’s chorus sing and dance their way through numbers that range from a country-and-western hoedown and calypso to 1970s disco and 1920s Charleston… Somehow, it works… the show feels well-paced, exciting, and interesting, from start to finish.” — Shelley Sackett, InSights · Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, North Shore Music TheatreRead the review
The American Five — Berkshire Theatre Group, 2026
“A passionate and compelling piece of theatre with humanity and wit,” praising McIntyre’s “pinpoint direction and choreography” — Berkshire on StageRead more (BTG release)
Young Frankenstein — Berkshire Theatre Group, 2024
“Gerry McIntyre has directed and choreographed a flawless production” — Berkshire Fine Arts (Charles Giuliano)Read the review
“His dancing is ideal for this show, never over-much and never too little.” — The Berkshire EdgeRead the review
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat — La Mirada Theatre, 2023
“Joyful, dazzling, and an all-around delight” — “helmed and choreographed with welcome high-energy succinctness by Gerry McIntyre” — BroadwayWorldRead the review
“Both razor-focused and efficient” (of his direction and choreography) — The Show ReportRead the review
Bonnie & Clyde — Pioneer Theatre Company, 2024
“Directed and choreographed, with a sure and steady hand, by Gerry McIntyre” — Gephardt DailyRead the review
The Scottsboro Boys — Theatre Raleigh, 2019
“Directed and brilliantly choreographed by Gerry McIntyre” — BroadwayWorldRead the review
Oklahoma! — Berkshire Theatre Group, 2013
“The fabulous choreography of the brilliant Gerry McIntyre” — Berkshire Fine ArtsRead the review
Ain’t Too Proud — Ogunquit Playhouse, 2026
“Director Gerry McIntyre keeps the show moving, but he never lets the speed crowd out the show’s emotional core.” — BroadwayWorldRead the review
Spamilton — Off-Broadway, 2016 (production quote — Gerry was the show’s choreographer)
“Smart, silly and convulsively funny!” — The New York Times (Ben Brantley), on the productionVia Menier Chocolate Factory
Godspell — Berkshire Theatre Group, 2020
Playbill’s feature on the first Equity-approved musical of the COVID era is built around Gerry’s vantage point: “Equity’s First Approved Musical From the Eyes of Its Choreographer.” Read the Playbill featureFeatures & Interviews
- “Gerry McIntyre Gushes Over Ain’t Misbehavin’ at The Encore” — BroadwayWorld interview (2022): the career in his own words, including where “The Mayor of Broadway” comes from. Read the interview
- Entertainmentx podcast, episodes #131 & #132 — “Gerry McIntyre, ‘The Mayor of Broadway’” (July 2020): the two-part career conversation — Broadway performing years, directing and choreography, After the Storm. Listen · also on Podbean: Podbean
- “What Are Theatremakers Doing to Present Safe Productions?” — Playbill feature (2020) built around Gerry and Godspell, the first Equity-approved musical of the pandemic. Read the Playbill feature
- After the Storm — PopMatters review of Hilla Medalia’s documentary, which follows Gerry rebuilding with thirteen New Orleans teenagers after Hurricane Katrina — and calls him the project’s “very empathetic director/choreographer.” Read the review
- “York Theatre Company Welcomes Gerry McIntyre to Administrative Team” — BroadwayWorld (Sep 29, 2020): the Associate Artistic Director appointment announcement. Read the announcement